Security Forward Workshop & Dinner - 11 July 2018 – Guoman Tower Hotel & Tower Of London

Wednesday, 11 July 2018

Security Forward-Risk and Intelligence Forum's quarterly meeting was held on 11 July at The Guoman Tower Hotel with an unparalleled view overlooking London's iconic Tower Bridge.

Our first speaker was our own 'Speaker in Residence' and Senior Adviser, Lt Col Crispin Black MBE MPhil, who spoke about the various implications artificial intelligence may bring with its emergence into the world. The presentation titled "Artificial Intelligence: Miracle or Monster?" was incredibly thought-provoking right from the start with philosophical questions such as “what is consciousness?” and “what constitutes intelligence?” Crispin then touched on the computational failure of the algorithm named 'Ada' which Hillary Clinton’s campaign was heavily influenced by and reliant upon. The algorithm ran thousands of daily simulations to see what possible outcomes might have arisen in the United States Presidential election, but clearly this complex analytical algorithm still couldn’t account for the actions of rural voters. Crispin then dove deeper into the field of artificial intelligence by giving examples of supervised learning, unsupervised learning and the differences between them. Crispin also spoke of the triumphs of artificial intelligence such as AlphaGo conquering over 18-time world champion Lee Se-dol in the abstract strategy board game ‘Go’. The conversation then turned more towards the ethical implications of artificial intelligence once it becomes entangled with robotics. Crispin raised skepticism over the implementation of autonomous cars, but then delivered some key points as to why artificial intelligence may be better suited for aircraft, especially in times of emergency where human decision making may not be quick enough. Crispin also noted the ethical implications of artificial intelligence which was debated heavily by the entire forum and led us into our coffee break.

Our second speaker was Phil Cracknell from GCA Security, who is widely regarded as one of the top information security specialists in Europe. Phil gave a fascinating and informed presentation entitled “CISO’s need to speak the language of the Board” which highlighted the need to understand how to couch presentations to the Board in language that addressed the concerns of the Board. In many corporations there seems to be a disconnect between the Board, who see things from a strategic and risk perspective and the financial implications that that brings with it, as opposed to some CISO’s who focus more on technical issues and the cost implications which they see as necessary to achieve their internal objectives. Phil pointed out some of the key elements to consider, such as ‘Exposure’, ‘Agility’ and ‘Culture’. Not surprisingly there was a good deal of discussion, which was only stopped due to time constraints.

We then moved on to our regular ‘Sharing your current In-tray’ session in which participants introduced themselves and highlighted any key issues and concerns that were at the top of their In-tray. One of our most senior Members posed a question concerning how professional we are as Security Executives and what training and qualifications should be needed to be a Corporate Security Executive at a major corporation. It would appear that many corporate security executives learn ‘on the job’ and either have a military or security services background. The security function is also in danger of existing in a silo, as it is seen as separate from most other corporate functions. It is unusual for a head of Security to transition to the Board in the way that the heads of other functions often do. This is going to be a subject to be discussed again at future meetings.

The meeting then transferred to The Tower of London. As is traditional, Crispin or Michael suggests a cocktail. In a strange attempt to avoid us drinking BBQ sauce and bourbon (what?), Crispin decided that the weather called for champagne. What did he have in his crazed cocktail mind? We may find out in future. Following the drink at The Fusiliers Museum, and listening to shouts far beyond the Tower as the England-Croatia match ebbed and flowed, we had a lovely summer dinner. Our dinner speaker was Diana Darke, who has travelled extensively in the Middle East and spent over twenty years working in the intelligence and counter intelligence world. She is a fluent Arabic speaker and has restored a magnificent home in the World Heritage area of Damascus. Diana discussed her latest book, ‘The Merchant of Syria: A History Of Survival’, and a signed copy was given to all those present. The discussion was wide-ranging, but focused on past, present, and future mistakes, as well as the enduring importance and over-riding endurance of trust in all commercial relationships, especially those in war zones.

Our autumn meeting will take place on 10 October 2018.